With waiting times for mental health support services growing ever longer, could virtual reality be one answer to cutting waiting times?
Access to treatment issues
With one in four of us expected to experience a mental health problem at anytime, increasing access to treatment has become essential. But doing so is challenging. Therapists require extensive training, and the most effective forms of therapy involve coaching patients in everyday situations, which is time-consuming and costly.
Delivering psychological therapies in virtual reality (VR) may provide a solution. Here are three ways VR could transform mental health treatment.
1. “In-situ” coaching
The most successful therapeutic interventions help people modify how they think, react, and behave in the very situations they find most challenging. This could be anything from getting on a crowded bus, attending a social event, or simply leaving the house.
Humans tend to remember information best when we’re in the same physical or mental state as we were when the memory was initially formed. This is known as state-dependent learning.
So, for example, if we want someone to remember a technique that will help reduce their anxiety while food shopping, it’s generally best to visit a supermarket during the therapy session to train and practice the technique.
Such active “in-situ” coaching can rarely happen in mental health services because of factors like cost and time. This is where VR can help.
VR environments create immersive simulations of real-world settings, allowing you to walk around and interact with the environment as if it were real. You can enter the situations you typically find challenging and learn psychological techniques to overcome difficulties alongside a virtual or real-life therapist.
Crucially, although it is known that the VR environment is just a simulation, we nonetheless respond as we would in the corresponding real-world environment, both psychologically and physiologically. As a result, any learning that’s made in VR transfers to the real world.
In one study of 30 patients with severe paranoid beliefs, fear of real-world social situations was halved after a single VR coaching session. Similar findings have been seen for a range of other experiences, such as fears of height and social anxiety.
Not only is VR more practical, but people are generally more willing to enter virtual versions of the situations they find anxiety-provoking because they know it’s only a simulation. It’s also easier to repeatedly try things that are too scary or embarrassing to try in the real world.
VR scenarios can also be graded in difficulty or personalized for each person. In a VR study at the University of Oxford on treating fear of heights, participants began in the virtual atrium of a ten-story building and were then able to choose which floor to go to. The idea was to start practicing on the lower, less scary floors and work their way up as they became more confident.
VR also allowed the researchers to make some scenarios more fun for participants – such as having tasks where you rescued a kitten or had to pop bubbles. This added flexibility in how participants were able to confront their fear may be one reason why their reductions in fear of heights exceeded those seen in traditional exposure therapy.
The flexibility of VR also means it can be adapted to help treat a range of mental health problems. VR treatments have been developed for many other phobias, such as spiders, and other disorders, such as PTSD, social anxiety, depression, eating disorders, psychosis, and addiction.
Perhaps the most significant advantage of VR therapies is that they can be automated. This means that in VR, there can be a virtual coach with you who explains the treatment and teaches you the psychological techniques to try out.
For example, a team at Oxford University has developed a virtual coach named Nic, who is used in our ongoing research into VR for mental health treatment. Nic encourages users and gives them ideas of psychological techniques to try during treatment.
Virtual coaches like Nic can work like a therapist without a therapist actually needing to be present at every VR session. Instead, a graduate psychologist or peer supporter (such as someone who has lived through a similar experience) can lead the sessions with the user, providing support and guidance alongside the virtual coach.
Because many more graduate psychologists and peer supporters are available than highly trained therapists, VR therapy can help ensure more people can access the treatment they may need without delay. VR treatment is also likely to be more affordable for the same reason.
Continuous improvements to VR hardware mean it’s becoming increasingly affordable and feasible to use this technology in mental health services in the near future to treat a range of conditions. While it would never replace therapists, it could improve the number of people able to access therapy.
We all know that something needs to be done to find additional ways that mental health can be delivered to the patient on demand. It is also clear that spending long times on waiting lists does no one any good at all.
From the research, it seems that VR, along with the use of chatbot technology, could be one part of the toolkit in helping those who need support quickly to get the help they require in short order.
What are your views on the use of VR for mental health support? Would you use VR when seeking help? Tell us more in the comments.